Jorge Pullin, Ph.D.


Jorge Pullin, PhD
Professor and Hearne Chair of Theoretical Physics
Ph.D., 1988  Instituto Balseiro, Argentina
Louisiana State University
Department of Physics & Astronomy
241C Nicholson Hall, Tower Dr.
Baton Rouge, LA 708034001
(225) 5780464Office
Personal Home Page
LSU Relativity
Horace C. Hearne, Jr. Institute of Theoretical Physics
Research Interests
General Relativity
Quantum Gravity
I collaborate with Rodolfo Gambini, of the University of the Republic in Montevideo, Uruguay, our collaboration has been going on since 1990. We coauthored a book "Loops, knots, gauge theories and quantum gravity" in 1996 and have published many papers together. We study the quantization of general relativity using canonical methods. There is a small community pursuing this kind of research, which is complementary to the mainstream approach to quantum gravity: string theory. String theorists believe that one cannot quantize general relativity because it is not a fundamental theory and one has to replace it with string theory in order to quantize it. General relativity will be an "effective" "low energy" theory.
Those of us who work in canonical quantization believe that it has not been properly shown that one cannot quantize plain old general relativity in four spacetime dimensions. It is clear that there are difficulties, but these are expected since we have never quantized a theory of spacetime itself. Worse, we have little experience theories that are invariant under diffeomorphisms (this is the technical description for the fact that general relativity is coordinateinvariant), and mostly with theories that are considerably simpler than general relativity.
A great place to read more about the canonical vs string debate is Lee Smolin's book "Three roads to quantum gravity". Read my review for Physics Today of the book.
Canonical quantum gravity picked momentum when Ashtekar introduced a new set of variables that make the theory resemble YangMills theories in 1986. Rovelli and Smolin noted in 1988 that one could use loop techniques to describe the theory. Gambini had introduced with Antoni Trias similar techniques for YangMills theories in the early 80's.
With Gambini we made several discoveries, including the fact that the celebrated Jones polynomial of knot theory appeared to solve the quantum Einstein equations. More recently we have been preoccupied with the use of lattice techniques to regularize the quantum Einstein equations. We have invented a generalization of Hamiltonian mechanics that applies to discrete systems like lattice theories and applied it to gravity. Remarkably, it appears to provide a consistent quantization of general relativity. This does away with conceptual problems that have plagued the subject, but leaves us with a challenging computational problem on the lattice. We expect to make progress in specific situations (for instance quantum cosmology) soon.
Black Hole Collisions
The collision of two black holes is a central problem in gravitational physics these days since it is expected that the LIGO interferometric gravitational wave detector will be able to measure gravitational waves produced by such collisions with a frequency of a few a year. This motivated the Grand Challenge Alliance of all the numerical relativity groups in the US to try to tackle the problem using supercomputers. In an article with Richard Price we showed that important progress could be made towards the computation of radiated energies and waveforms using the "close approximation". This approximation is based upon the fact that when the two black holes are close to each other they become surrounded by a common horizon and for all practical purposes they look like a distorted black hole. That can be treated using the well established perturbation theory of black holes. The results are astounding.
This approach has developed quite a bit over the last decade, you can read more in my Canada conference review talk. Some of these ideas have now been further extended and developed into a whole new paradigm for binary black holes callled the Lazarus Project centered at University of Texas at Brownsville.
Since moving to LSU, we have build a group that attempts to solve the Einstein equations for the binary black hole problem using supercomputers. We are happy that LSU hosts the fastest supercomputer in the world controlled by a university. You can get the latest developments of our group at the Hearne Institute homepage.
Current and Selected Publications
 "Quantum mechanics, strong emergence and ontological nonreducibility," Rodolfo Gambini, Lucia Lewowicz and Jorge Pullin, Found Chem (2015) 17:117127. Springer Science + Business Media Dordrecht 2015.
 Miguel Campiglia, Rodolfo Gambini, and Jorge Pullin, "Loop quantization of spherically symmetric midisuperspaces," Class. Quant. Grav. 24, 36493672 (2007). [ePrint: grqc/0703135]
 Rodolfo Gambini, Rafael A. Porto, and Jorge Pullin, "Fundamental spatiotemporal decoherence: A key to solving the conceptual problems of black holes," Int. J. Mod. Phys. D 15, 21812186 (2006).
[ePrint: grqc/0611148]
 Miguel Campiglia, Cayetano Di Bartolo, Rodolfo Gambini, and Jorge Pullin, "Uniform discretizations: A New approach for the quantization of totally constrained systems," Phys. Rev. D 74, 124012 (2006).
[ePrint: grqc/0610023]
 Rodolfo Gambini, and Jorge Pullin, "Relational physics with real rods and clocks and the measurement problem of quantum mechanics," Found. Phys. 37, 10741092, (2007). [ePrint: quantph/0608243]
 Gustavo Dotti, Reinaldo Gleiser, and Jorge Pullin, "Instability of charged and rotating naked singularities," Phys. Lett. B 644, 289293 (2007). [ePrint: grqc/0607052]
 Miguel Campiglia, Cayetano di Bartolo, Rodolfo Gambini, and Jorge Pullin, "Uniform discretizations: A Quantization procedure for totally constrained systems including gravity," J. Phys. Conf. Serv. 67, 012020 (2007). [ePrint: grqc/0606121]
